Ok here's a tally of the votes and where I got 'em from:
On the blog: 2 crochet, 2 knit
On Facebook: 2 crochet, 1 knit
In person: 3 crochet, 2 knit
On Twitter: 1 knit
So that means 7 votes for the crocheted pink ellie, 6 votes for the white knitted ellie. A close one, but the pink elephant wins. She's getting shipped off to Baby Asha this week. Thanks for the votes!